Geoffrey Smith leaves Jazz Record Requests
Geoffrey Smith, presenter of BBC Radio 3's Jazz Record Requests, is to leave the programme following a decision to refresh one of the BBC's oldest jazz features, writes MARK GILBERT
BBC Radio 3 has announced that following a "collaborative decision" to "refresh" its flagship Saturday afternoon programme Jazz Record Requests presenter Geoffrey Smith will move to the midnight slot from 5 May, where he will chair a new programme titled Geoffrey Smith's Jazz.
Relax with the luxurious print edition of Jazz Journal and enjoy more jazz news, reviews, features and debate.
"Refresh" = dilute, dumb-down. More girl singers. You get the picture
After Steve Race, Ken Sykora took over for a couple of years. Everybody forgets him. Let's hope that for the new JRR, that horrible signature tune is finally replaced!
Thanks, Paul - look out for interview with Geoffrey Smith in May JJ.
I'll miss your knowledgeable commentary on the music & players, you'll be a hard act to follow, Geoffrey! Best of luck with the new midnight jazz slot.
What a great loss to JRR! Saturday tea-time won't be the same without Geoffrey. I hope the 'refresh' does not dumb-down as predicted above (although there are some great girl singers around...)
Thank you Geoffrey for all the hours of wonderful varied jazz since 1991. And thanks BBC for the Listen Again facility.
So....."the occasional N.Y. Met Opera jockeyed JRR forward into a later position", did it? Well, yes, if occasionally means frequently, and forward means backward. And Geoff Smith is to move to the midnight-slot, which is a lot better than 2 am, innit. Swingin! P.R. P.R.
Thank you Geoffrey Smith for your wonderfully laconic presentation style over the last two decades. Looking forward to saying hel-lo your new programme. On a separate note, let's be clear that no one is under any illusion as to the true meaning of the terms "collaborative decision" and "refresh". Glad I've got plenty of Smith's Jazz Record Requests archived. :)
The playlist for Saturday's programme (with Mehldau and Neset) makes interesting reading in the context of the Geoffrey Smith interview in May Jazz Journal. GS says JRR is what it is and suggests 15-20 requests a week from a predominantly post sixtysomething audience. How many requests for 5 May prog and from where? Has a broader requests constituency been created in advance of the first new programme by polling a previously untapped area of the jazz community? Is a new platform being engineered in the context of pressure on R3 to reach out to new audiences (cf. the jollifications of Radio 3 Breakfast)?
Let's not pussyfoot around this any longer, we know full well how the BBC operates. One only has to acknowledge the present level of kowtowing in effect over the upcoming jubilee to understand whose interests are truly represented. Not that I'm suggesting the old queen herself had a personal hand in the Radio 3 "refresh". Although the premise does conjure some amusing scenarios.
Of course they plan to "engineer" the sound and personality of the programme from now on, as Mark Gilbert's reference to the latest playlist fairly indicates. A truer picture as to the full extent of this shall become more apparent after a few months as they attempt to make the process seem like a natural change or, as it was doubtless pitched at the meeting, organic.
It would be naive to think a corporation the size of the BBC does not have an agenda of some kind of course, but one that favours an out-of-touch and biased BBC Trust and ignores its investors - its actual listeners and licence payers, of course - is one that shall be its eventual collapse. I've already suggested elsewhere that Alyn Shipton continues the truncated Jazz Library in the JRR slot. It's not as if anyone from the Trust will be listening is it?
I've not been around at the right time to listen JRR recently but this evening I am. It's rather like being in one of those pseudo sophisticated bars of a tasteless hotel and being addressed by the smoothie who, between records, is chatting up the peroxide blond behind the bar. Please can we have Geoffrey Smith back at a reasonable time.
This new chap is too bland. Just highlights how professional and refreshing GS is.
How can Saturday nights ever be the same? How we will all miss Geoffrey's relaxed, suave and polished commentary. "Refresh"?! "Collaborative"?! I think we all know what these clichés really mean. Miss J. Mitchell was so right: You never know what you've got 'til it's gone. Thank you Geoffrey for all these happy listening years. Now all we have to do is stay awake 'round midnight - and we will, that's for sure.
Peter Clayton and Geoffrey Smith made my Saturday afternoons for decades. All good things come to an end but I am sure the BBC is, as ever, lying about the real reason. Oh well, have to listen to GS with my cocoa. Good-BYE!
Paul Acton: Just twigged - Ken Sykora is the subject of a new film, details in the June issue of JJ and later a review. A fine guitar player in the Hot Club style - see the trailer here - and a Desert Island Discs subject in 1962, unfortunately (no surprise) not available as a BBC Listen Again but his selections are shown here, from Max Bruch to Django.
Thank you for remembering my dad, Ken Sykora. The Man With The Jazz Guitar is playing during the Glasgow Jazz Festival at the Glasgow Film Theatre 27th and 28th June. Please go to the website for earlier dates in Ipswich and Dunoon. Five Feet Films have a copy of the original Desert Island Discs programme featuring dad and intend to offer it to the BBC for inclusion in their online series.
Great news that Five Feet have a copy of the Desert Island Discs with Ken Sykora. Kind regards - MG
Perhaps it's something to do with when you first started listening to JRR and my favourite was always Peter Clayton. When he died it was like losing a friend. I'll miss Geoffrey Smith's show too but he's very knowledgeable and it'll be nice to hear him stretch out a bit. Alyn Shipton is a great presenter and his Jazz Library was a return to form for the BBC's jazz programming. He'll do a great job on JRR.
After listening to the 'refreshed' programme I can only say the change was not for the better. The selection from listeners' requests just seems so dull.
Saturday evenings will never be the same again! We used to love 'he--llo' and that inimitable voice. Alyn Shipton is just so bland; do they really think he's going to attract younger listeners? Only one thing for it, we shall have to "listen again" to GS at a more convenient time.
Guess I've listened to my last JRR, then. With respect to Mr Shipton, Geoffrey is irreplaceable.
Well GS seems quite pleased with this change, however, he has now been relegated to the graveyard shift as was John Peel. An equal lack of respect by the execs at the BBC?
Sorry, but the decision to take GS off JRR is a mistake. All due respect to Alyn, but really, he just doesn't have the style of Geoffrey. I can remember some ten years ago that he played a blues jazz type track from one Jimi Hendrix! Good byyyyyyye
It's been a few months now since the introduction of the 'new' JRR, so I feel I can now comment on the content. A track by Steely Dan was played last week, this would have never been considered in the past, (I don't care if Victor Feldman and Wayne Shorter are on it, they were just there for the money). Also there seems to be much more meandering tuneless world music featured which doesn't fit the description of jazz. I don't think it's Alyn Shipton's fault. He certainly knows his subject, and his previous Jazz Library programmes were excellent. It's down to BBC manipulation. Where have all these non jazz requests suddenly come from? I'm sure nobody dared to send in such requests when the others were in charge.
When I originally heard Alyn Shipton presenting JRR I assumed he was a stand-in for a vacationing Geoffrey Smith. Smith is a wonderful presenter..warm, charismatic, informative, humorous, irreplaceable !!! What IS going on ? Shipton sounds like a robot by comparison...& where have the track personnel listings gone ? Bring back Geoffrey immediately before Shipton's sleep inducing blandness loses all your listeners !!
Golly, gosh, it's taken a very long time indeed to get around to realising, acknowledging the fact that Geoffrey has gone. Crikey, I want to say no, don't go, man. You have the voice, the style, the charisma for at least another twenty years. Am I getting sycophantic? No, you are just the business, one voice that lets me, let me, ride over the trad, lollopy, items that you were obliged to present in that fatherly, loving way you did. Now I have to buy a Roberts radio to ensure I can record your dulcet tones and you won't go missing. I can't have that when I might get wrecked on that desert island and I need my eight records, one of which must contain your voice. More later, let there be much more... later.
Can honestly say I Havent listened to j.r.r since heard the news that G.S had been moved to the graveyard shift..Gutted! Have the guys in charge have no idea! Refresh what! Get G.S back on! Saturday afternoons havent been the same since..Ps nothing against A.S just not the same..
I can only agree with Merk Tain's comment and add that myself (aged 40) and two teenagers (aged 17 and 16) still miss Geoffrey's Jazz Record Requests dreadfully. I am sorry too that Alyn Shipton just doesn't have that lively yet chilled tone that somehow just means Saturday afternoons. We were worried something dreadful had happened to Geoffrey because why else would they change it. We love Radio 3 but JRR was one of the highlights. Genius combination.
All downhill since Peter Clayton and Charles Fox - they were the real guys.